Girlhood vs When Happiness Had a Holiday : Helping Families Improve and Strengthen Their Relationships

Both "Girlhood" by Carolyn Hays and "When Happiness Had a Holiday : Helping Families Improve and Strengthen Their Relationships" by Maeve McColgan are popular choices for readers interested in transgender and trans woman. This comparison helps you decide which to read first — or whether both belong on your list.

Shared Themes

parenting
Cover of Girlhood

Girlhood

Carolyn Hays

2022

'Stunning . . . Built like a thriller, moving, wise and illuminated on every page with love' -Joanne Harris, author of Chocolat A parent's deeply moving love letter to a daughter who has always known exactly who she is. When Carolyn Hays's child made clear to the family that they were all wrong, he was not a boy, but, in fact, a girl, the Hays shifted pronouns, adopted a nickname and encouraged her to dress as she felt comfortable. One ordinary day, a caseworker from the Department of Children and Families knocked on their door to investigate an anonymous complaint about the upbringing of their transgender child. It was this threat that instilled in them a deep-seated fear for their child's safety in the Republican state they called home. And so they uprooted their lives to the more trans-accepting Northeast United States, though they were never far from the hate and fear resting at the nation's core. Intimate, lyrical and thought-provoking, A Girlhood is an ode to Hays's brilliant, brave child, as well as a cathartic revisit of the pain of the past. It tells of the brutal truths of being trans, of the sacrificial nature of motherhood, and of the lengths a family will go to shield their youngest from the cruel realities of the world. Hays asks us all to love better, for children everywhere enduring injustice and prejudice just as they begin to understand themselves. A Girlhood is a celebration of difference, a plea for empathy, a hope for a better future, but moreover, it is a love letter to a child who has always known herself and is waiting for the rest of the world to catch up.

Published 2022
Books like Girlhood
Cover of When Happiness Had a Holiday : Helping Families Improve and Strengthen Their Relationships

When Happiness Had a Holiday : Helping Families Improve and Strengthen Their Relationships

Maeve McColgan

2020

For effective use, this book should be purchased alongside the professional guidebook. Both books can be purchased together as a set, When Happiness Had a Holiday: Helping Families Improve and Strengthen their Relationships [9780367860547] This beautifully illustrated therapeutic storybook has been designed to support children and families to strengthen their relationships using solution-focused brief therapy. Healthy and supportive family relationships are essential to mental health, and as referrals to Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services continue to rise, growing research demonstrates the benefit of involving families in the treatment of children and young people facing emotional and mental health difficulties. The storybook explores the struggles faced by a typical family in which relationships have become more tense and conflictual. It can be used to spark discussion about the struggles faced by a family, and the ways in which these struggles can be overcome when they work together. This book features: An engaging story with attractive illustrations, enabling difficult issues to be explored in a child-friendly manner An accessible and relateable narrative that allows for a discussion of family difficulties without assigning blame Several suggestions for practical steps that can be taken to allow happiness to return to a family. This is a vital resource for social workers, counsellors, mental health professionals and individual and family psychotherapists working with families and children. Also available is an accompanying workbook with resources and activities: When Happiness Had a Holiday: Helping Families Improve and Strengthen their Relationships: A Professional Resource.

Published 2020
Books like When Happiness Had a Holiday : Helping Families Improve and Strengthen Their Relationships

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is easier to read: Girlhood or When Happiness Had a Holiday : Helping Families Improve and Strengthen Their Relationships?
Reading difficulty depends on your familiarity with the genre. Check each book's page count and subject matter above, and start with whichever aligns better with books you've enjoyed before.
Can I read Girlhood and When Happiness Had a Holiday : Helping Families Improve and Strengthen Their Relationships in any order?
Yes — these are standalone works. You don't need to read one before the other unless they're part of the same series.
Which book is better for beginners?
If you're new to this genre, look at the shorter book with broader appeal and start there. You can always come back for the other.

Are you an author? Promote your book or submit a free listing.

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases. Book links on this page may be affiliate links. This does not affect our recommendations or the price you pay.